share email twitter ⋅ join discord whatsapp(2ck)
Free 120  NBME 24  NBME 23  NBME 22  NBME 21  NBME 20  NBME 19  NBME 18  NBME 17  NBME 16  NBME 15  NBME 13 
search for anything NEW!
NBME 20 Answers

nbme20/Block 2/Question#8 (56.4 difficulty score)
Three elderly residents of an assisted living ...
Legionella pneumophila🔍,📺
tags:

Login to comment/vote.


Tutor box

Members from the Leaderboard offering 1-on-1 help: Want to be listed here? Email us!

 +4 
submitted by usmle11a(83),
unscramble the site ⋅ remove ads ⋅ become a member ($39/month)

ilgllaoene : vrey moncom in vdecdana eag, ,OPCD mpuiosenrsumsped pietsnat dan " gnoig bakc mfro a sceenedir hal"l ihcwh blrobpya dha a aidcetmotann XA setmsy lcbay(slia fits evyre eno ni het Q)

endoa X : odluw tepnsre hiwt tvusiiocijc,ntn rtahot ipna uf.l.. :vsiur nto eoeenyrv ogt eth deiessa R:SV on hndicrle e tprs umeonp: wdlou atgetr a egalrr auplnopiot fo halythe oeplep as lewl.

bharatpillai  why would they say that the only people who didnt get affected by the disease were people on steroids (lupus nephritis and severe asthma) couldnt have been rsv since it causes croup in children. strep pneumo would cause fever and other systemic signs. i went for adenovirus because uworld says most common causes of copd excacerbation are viral infections... +3  
brbwhat  I went for adeno forr the same reason. I guess the MAIN HINT is that this is not a copd exacerbation. Since people without prexesting copd also had pneumonia, also people with copd exacerbation will have different presenting symptoms, here it was told, that we are told that dx was penumonia. People with copd exacerbation wouldn’t be diagnosed with pneumonia if it was an adenovirus infections. +3  
j44n  adenovirus doesnt cause pneumonia its just makes the current COPD sx worse +1  
j44n  the SLE and asthmatic patient were both considered slightly immunosupressed or theyre just more likely to get something (SLE pt= your B cells are too busy making Ig's to kill your kidney, and the asthmatic is on corticosteroids that aopotose your t cells) but they're not COPD patients so the pneumonmia wont be as severe, all in all legionella causes really really bad pneumonia in COPD patients and less severe (pontiac fever) in those with mild immunosupression +4  



 +2 
submitted by stepwarrior(23),

I ruled out most of them because of no evidence of person-to-person transmission and only people with pre-existing conditions were affected. The rest would probably also affect children or other attendees or spread to others in the nursing home.




 +1 
submitted by allinthistogether(1),
unscramble the site ⋅ remove ads ⋅ become a member ($39/month)

nailoLeleg si onocmm saeucs fo apmeounni rpesdimsouep no nrcciho vuistortbce lmuyprona eediass.

asapdoc  Im pretty sure so is strept pneumoniae +4  
usmleuser007  COPD is also exacerbated by Viral infection: Rhinovirus, influenza, parainfluenza; and Bacterial infection: Haemophilus influenzae, Moraxella catarrhalis, Streptococcus. however, the questions gives a hint that it may be legionella = "weekend retreat" which may be associated with this infection +5  
loopers  From FA 2017 pg 139: Legionnaires’ disease—severe pneumonia (often unilateral and lobar A ), fever, GI and CNS symptoms. Common in smokers and in **chronic lung disease.** +2  
kentuckyfan  I also believe that the other attendees showed signs of pontiac fever, which is another hint they tried to get at. +3  
luke.10  i did it wrong and chose influenza virus since it is most common infection in COPD but the clue in the Question is that the other attendee didnt get sick since in legionella there is no person to person transmission +2  
endochondral   but in Uworld s. pneumo is one of the most common bacterial exacerbation of COPD legionella wasn't even mentioned. How do we rule out s. pneumo ? +5  
nala_ula  maybe because in children s.pneumo causes otitis media? +  
smc213  Another hint made in the Q stem is the location being rural Pennsylvania.... Legionnaires disease was first discovered by the outbreak in 1976 at a convention held in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Not sure why I know this fact... +9  
hpsbwz  Biggest hint towards legionella to me was that they all were at a residence hall... i.e. where there'd be air conditioners and such. +6  

formatting got messed up and now its unreadable - lets try again

legionella because it's an environmental source (residence hall), no person to person transmission, SUPERIMPOSED pneumonia (NOT a COPD exacerbation)

common bacteria for superimposed - H. flu, legionella, morexella catarrhalis (pathoma)

COPD exacerbations usually described as progressively worsening dyspnea and cough, change in sputum; more often viral than bacterial/fungal (UW)

+3/- lynn(12),