support the site ⋅
become a member ⋅
unscramble the egg

NBME 21 Answers ↦

nbme21/Block
4/Question#11
(32.7 *difficulty score*)

A study is conducted on patients with asthma ...

If the treatment really changes the mean asthma score by 0.4, there is an 80% chance that a study of this size will find a p-value < 0.05🔍

tags:

A study is conducted on patients with asthma ...

If the treatment really changes the mean asthma score by 0.4, there is an 80% chance that a study of this size will find a p-value < 0.05🔍

tags:

Login to comment/vote.

privatejoker
This one took me a minute and was during the last block so my brain was already fried. But my reasoning was that, as stated above, since it gave you power, it is basically just a long-winded way of asking what Power is, and how this relates to p-value. P-value is the odds that the finding was due to chance alone. Obviously a p-value set to <0.05 implies a greater than 95% chance that the finding is legit. Since the power is said to be 80%, this means that there is an 80% chance that the study finding is legit, at least insomuch that it met the pre-set criteria of being 95% non-chance related.
+

sahusema
80% chance (power) the study correctly identifies the existence of an association in reality. If an association is determined to exist, >95% chance the study and reality agree with each other (p<.05)
+1

unscramble the site ⋅
become a member
($36/month)

Bklac hPowa!

oaPwh = 1 - AETB = ad trae fo med ERTU ETPSIS;IOV uwz da erta ta ihwhc oyu get da etru teovissip sorcsa a nhcuab ts?sediu 80% here hbur

A NOTE TO SIMPLE MINDED STUDENTS LIKE MYSELF ! :

First Step : Power is probability or chance ( that a study will detect a true difference) . So cancel out every single option that says 80 % of subjects ( And I mean every single one of them !!) which is basically every single option from A to D

Second Step : this leaves you with only option E and F which are now questioning your understanding of the p value ( again a probability /chance thats a study will detect a difference when none exists )
In our study all the values obtained were associated with a p value of 0.035 i.e less than 0.05.

(OPTION F )

Third Step : Pick option F

You will find that most of these questions are just a play on words - 80 % probability vs 80 % of subjects to test whether you understand what the term really means

unscramble the site ⋅
become a member
($36/month)

08% chenca ewr(po) eth tsudy ccoeyrrtl tfeiseindi eth xctneiese of na cnosstoiiaa in atlyeri. If an sicatnsaioo is edrnedimet ot sx,eti &5gt9%; ccahne eht yustd dna rlayite raege twih hcae heort (t5l.)p0&;

Power = ability to detect a difference between groups (if one exists) P value (<0.05) = probability that results were due to random chance

80% power = 80% chance of the study being able to detect symptom changes, which in this case was 0.4 (AKA 80% chance of detecting a significant p value)

submitted by imgdoc(127), 2019-07-01T19:52:54Z

csylliBaa hist qionuste tusj assk thwa" si weo"rp dna ssak oyu ot aenlpix htta %08 wpro.e owrPe si 1 - tbae e(typ 2 )rro,er baclalsyi enwh a fenfeeidcr seitsx adn teh lnul hsopsithey si edtjecre si woep.r So fi teh xR cedtset a naem fecerdfien of 4.0 in mathas in teh atitsepn ni hte ntrtaeemt rgu,po nhte taht adta lfals in eht 08% porwe e,ganr nda sit nncfiagsecii is %95 0;5.()lpt&,0 P avuel is utjs hte pbioriaylbt of mteonihgs ngapepnih by aenh,cc so you ahwt itsh to be less hatt 5% os tevhrwea oyu bvsedore st'in ihbls.lut

I hoep shit ehpe,dl dan ocertcr em fi I'm .gwnro